When I receive a book for review and I don’t like it, I am always a bit hesitant before writing down my thoughts for everyone to read. You see, there are books that work for many of us, books that work for some of us.. and books that simply doesn’t work for me no matter how interesting the concept might seem to be at first sight.
..This goes in the last category. *sigh*
There are a few reasons why this story didn’t work for me.
1. First because it is full of clichés:
- golden couple not so golden *already seen*,
- antisocial guy that likes the girl and the girl that likes him back – secretly *surprise, surprise*,
- school project that makes them work together resulting in awkward moments and the golden boy acting like an ape-man (because a girl can’t possibly work with a boy without her boyfriend being excessively possessive *sigh*),
- girl that needs to break up with golden boy, but doesn’t because.. no reasons? *eye roll*,
- instant attraction with no background between girl and antisocial boy,
And so on..
I feel like I’ve seen it all before, but if you didn’t, then that’s a good thing because you might actually get to enjoy a bit this story.
2. Then, the story is a bit short, so there is not much development – not in terms of character development, neither plot-related. There are many things happening that should be important, but never really felt so or never got to that point; there was this suspense that didn’t make sense because we were left hanging in mid-air.
3. Also, the domestic violence was something that I didn’t like at all, not because it existed, but because it was poorly managed.
I know things like that might happen in real life: boy beats the girl and she does nothing, never leaves the relationship (even though in this case she had a reason: she didn’t even have feelings for the abuser anymore and she liked someone else; she wasn’t even tied by some good memories – as many abused girls seem to be). But I wished for this girl to make a difference, to set an example for these girls reading the book (that are young probably and don’t know better). But *sigh* she never did.
The only interesting part on my side was the ending.
I am not saying that it was done the way I wanted it (as it felt pretty rushed and I was already losing interest to make myself care much about it), but at least it made me feel something nice toward this novel. It didn’t change my perception of this story, but it felt refreshing after all the clichés.
We meet the main characters after they fall one for the other (of course they have no idea that the feeling is mutual) – so it doesn’t make much sense for them not to even try to be together, not to interact in any way, and most of all it doesn’t make sense that Evie is still in a relationship with a boy that treats her the way he does – I’m talking about someone punching his girlfriend and I would add rape to the list too – as forcing someone to have sex with you, even when you have a relationship together, is just the same.
Note: Girls should know that this is not right – this is not an example, this (I assume that) only shows things that happen, for you to understand how wrong they are and for you to make better decisions in real life.
Then, talking about Chace, his reason for being an outcast was not a very solid one.
Let me tell you something: I know that there are people out there that grew up without their parents, that went through traumatic experiences, I really hope that they are able to get a hold of the situation and really live their lives (at least in the memory of the ones that don’t have that chance anymore). They don’t deserve less in life because of what they went through, it’s quite the opposite, they deserve more happiness to balance the suffering. It should NEVER make them feel less, it should only make them stronger.
And if you are a lucky one, with a happy life, but you know people like the above, please.. don’t you ever look down them, you are not better, you just have a easy life – that’s all. I don’t get the bullying thing, why treat others so bad? What good does that to one?
The character I liked the most was Evie’s father – he was not present, but his words were ringing in my head at all times. I am not sure though why Evie didn’t listen to his advices if she knew them so well. But even he had his flaws and I am not sure why did we start liking him only to see him make his own mistakes. *shaking head*
Talking about mixed feelings about some characters, Evie’s best friend was one of those too. She gave good advices, but even though I knew where she was headed I didn’t understand her reasons. Why do the mistakes you try to keep others from doing? And people, please stop using alcohol as an excuse for everything stupid you do. You don’t become a whole different person when you’re drunk, you just have no moral restrictions so you do what you please without second thoughts – and you should really question yourself if you are the kind of person that acts entirely differently when drunk.. just saying.
But maybe this is a good thing, that no character is perfect, that making mistakes it’s in our nature (of course, only if we learn from them). Still, you need to know when to help yourself, when to make better judgements, when to move on.
The lines between good and bad, between good choices and bad ones are not so easy to be seen, but we have to struggle and find those ways that make us happy, that are good for us and focus on them.
I really wanted to like this story, I really wanted to care more for the characters and be more emotionally invested in what happened to them through the story, but for various reasons this never happened. Maybe because I read similar books before and I felt that there was nothing new to it, maybe because I prefer better developed characters, flawed but also stronger, more complex. Maybe because there was little action until the ending and by then I felt somehow exhausted, skimming through it more than reading.
Anyways… I always feel bad when I don’t like a story, because books are supposed to make me feel good, or a better person, or to teach me something.. or at least to entertain me (and make me think “how silly am I for reading this?”).
- If you liked this story you might like also Falling For You by Lisa Schroeder, a book that I had some of the same problems with – and unfortunately didn’t get to the end of it (Maybe it did get better, who knows? Maybe I’ll try it again another time.).
- If you want my recommendation on this subject (abuse), I remember loving Stay by Deb Caletti, so you might want to check it out.
- If you like characters working on projects together: Nevermore by Kelly Creagh (which is darker and a lot more complex); The DUFF by Kody Keplinger; there’s a bit of this concept in Unravelling by Elizabeth Norris… and if I remember others I’ll add them to the list.
Happy midnight reading!
Book Source: ARC received for review. Thank you!
I know how you feel. I hate it too when I don’t like a book. Sorry this didn’t work for you hun 🙁
Yeah.. well, like I always say – not al books are for all people. 🙂
I got to re-read some of my favorite books and they made me forget about the books I didn’t enjoy.
I don’t think this one would work for me, mostly because of the reasons why it didn’t completely do it for you. It’s difficult not to compare books like this to the other better titles out there, especially when you read so much. Great review, Ari. 🙂
That’s true. Looking back to the books I enjoyed first when I started reading YA sometimes they don’t seem like some stories that I would possibly enjoy now.
Now I need stronger plots, well developed characters that stay true to themselves no matter what, dialogue lines that I could picture in real life, turnarounds that would made me turn page after page like there’s no tomorrow… well, you get the point.
Reading a lot seems like a ‘blessing and a curse’ (not my words, I am not that profound, LOL) as we get to be quite picky after a while ;))
Sorry you didn’t enjoy it. Thanks for the honest review.
It was at least a quick read and it didn’t take me too long to finish reading it 🙂
So many books seem to use the same ‘recipe’. Sometimes I wish they’d come up with some more original ideas, as reading about the same things over and over is tiresome indeed.
Sorry it didn’t work for you, I hope you’re enjoying your re-reading time though 😉
Yes, I did enjoy the books I read once more (on the list I have Jellicoe Road, The Lumatere Chronicles, Graffiti Moon – all great books if you ever need something to read).
And you are right, the first time you read something it feels great, but if you find the same concept in many other books you get tired of it, no matter how differently portrayed it is.
I just wanted to know I love your blog! I keep playing around with your sun up there 😀
And it’s a shame that you didn’t like this book, but there are so many books in this world, I bet you’ve already found some others that you’ll like 😉
Oh, thank you, jessi! I am happy to hear that 🙂
I am waiting for a few books right now, hopefully I will enjoy them a lot more.
Thanks for your honest review!
Well.. it’s not quite a pleasure to write low rated reviews, but that’s what we do, right, stay honest even when it’s a bit hard. Thanks for stopping by!
I hate it when you want to like a book so much, but it reminds you a lot of several other books that didn’t work out for you. I think some of the issues you mentioned, such as the cliched aspects really wouldn’t work out for me either. Which is a shame, as this novel sounds like it can deliver. But thank you for the honest review Ari and I like the recommendations bit you’ve added at the bottom. I’ve always wanted to read Stay by Deb Caletti, so think I will give that a try instead!
Probably like 5 years ago I would have liked it a bit more.
I don’t think I would have loved it, but without being tired of reading about the same things I would’ve been able to see it in a different light (I can’t be sure though).
If I remember right, Stay shows the aftermath of abuse, the (psychological) consequences on a person, but also giving us a look at how these relationships start and evolve. I am just sorry that I didn’t write an actual review back then *sigh* But I hope that you will enjoy the story.