To be honest, I was absolutely sure that I would love this story, even with the funny (though a bit unfortunate) title. And don’t get me wrong, the story is cute and quite amusing, for a younger audience it might sound much better anyways, but there were some things that made my rating drop a bit.
Gia is very immature.
Her problems with Jules made me laugh in frustration (because there was nothing left that I could do) and I wanted to shake them both for being so stupid. Yes, I do remember my teenage years and I was probably just as foolish in some ways, but it still didn’t sit well with me. If only there was one good reason for their fights!
Then there were more things..
Like, the fact that her other friends were just as shallow as Gia, her parents made me want to scream at them to get real (they weren’t bad parents per see, but they seemed not to care much about their kids and I never understood why that was) and her brother (though he was so right about everything in the movie) should have known better than to go around hiding things and assuming that he had permission for what he did.
The reason for the fill-in boyfriend was ridiculous in this context.
I did get Hayden’s take on it later on (though he didn’t actually ask her to play that part), but for Gia it was all about shallow appearances and friends validation. And I get that this was the whole point, for her to grow up and finally be herself without the approval of the others, but it still didn’t make me like her much.
On the other side…
Hayden was really great.
A bit dorky, in a cute kind of way, and with a bit of an emotional baggage, but very sweet and just what Gia needed in order to become real, instead of the a cardboard copy of a teen that she actually was.
Also, his sister was a bit sharp-tongued, but nice – when & if you actually got to know her. I liked her shy side and I liked just how supportive she was. I only wish to know what happened with her story.
What I loved the most was the movie.
Gia can be all the upset she wants, but that movie defined her perfectly. I am not even sure why was she so upset (or the others) as that was exactly the kind of life that she lived – hidden behind social media sites and gadgets, trying to be popular and not caring about anything real. It was not a parody, her brother didn’t mean to make fun of her, there were just pieces of her life on screen. And I understand why it hurt so badly, but it didn’t take away the fact that it was real.
The only thing the movie didn’t show enough, tough it hinted to it, was the influence of the parents in this.
Because this is the real first problem of the new generation.
Not only for teens with their social addiction, but also for little kinds that hide behind those damned games on their ipads instead of actually playing, running, laughing, screaming, hiking each piece of furniture and thinking they are at the top of the world. And the fault… It belongs to the parents.
Dear parents, it’s your fault that your kids don’t know how to be real anymore, that they hide behind their phones and live virtual lives. They’ve learned it from you. So make sure to set the right example in the future!
I am a bit sad that this was not explored enough, there was so much potential here, but I do understand how the author wanted to make the teens aware of this problem without beating them over their heads with it (as that would not be the way to go, not at all)
This is a light, cute story about self discovery and the importance of truth and trust. It’s a quick read with a few very great insights, and even though it is not my favourite from this author I still think that you should give it a try – if you think that it’s a story that might appeal to you 😉
PS: If you like the concept, you can also check The Art of Layney (it’s another cute book about fake boyfriends).
Enjoy them both!
I was absolutely sure I would love this story too. The Fill-In Boyfriend was on my list of fluffy novels for my beach bag. Hey I know summer vacation is two month away but bookworm can never be too early prepared lol
I loved The Art of Lainey. Perfect little cute book. 🙂
Now your review leaves me… in doubt. I haven’t’ read anything by Kasie West. What would you recommend as a start?
Yeah, I thought it would be the perfect summer book for me, but somehow it failed to reach my expectations. Then again, it never helps to read a book similar to what you’ve read end enjoyed before (because the pressure for it to be better or at least as good is pretty high).
I loved Pivot Point from this author (it is paranormal, with alternate futures from which to choose) and I also loved On The Fence (summer best-friends romance, for me one of the best out there – really cute and funny). You can click on the author’s name on the top of the page and get to all the reviews I wrote for her books.
I do enjoy her writing and she is an author I keep an eye on and I will definitely try everything she writes. It’s just that this book was my least favourite one probably.
Oh, that is always the worst. As you said it you just can’t stop yourself from comparing and it’s sad when you know that you would have liked the second book much more if the first one was not so awesome…
Alternatives futures and best-friends romance are one of my favorite themes. Now I don’t know what to do. I’ll just have to read them both. Although since the summer is near I am leaning toward reading ‘On The Fence’ first…
For some reason, during summer I tend to read more romantic stories too, not sure really why. These books, they are both good – On the Fence is a standalone, while Pivot Point has a sequel. I’ll wait and see what you think of them 🙂
I’m really sad you didn’t love this one like the others. I really enjoyed it, but wasn’t my fave either. I was really mad with the ending.
I’ve been waiting for it for quite a while and I wanted to love it so badly, but this doesn’t mean that I don’t appreciate this author – it was just a book that wasn’t for me. I can’t wait for her next one 😉
PS: yes, it seemed like I was missing some chapters from the book, I needed to know more about both couples, but open endings give hope, so at least we have that 🙂